Andrew Gaines

I think there is only one thing. Young people will have hope when they see that society as a whole is passionately committed to transitioning to a life-affirming global culture, rather than continuing on our present course of ecological self-destruction and societal breakdown.

How would they know that this commitment exists?

Just as in wartime everyone speaks about the war, so people everywhere would be talking about transitioning to a life-affirming global culture. Politicians would affirm this as our goal (rather than economic increase). They would justify policy decisions on the basis of their contribution to evolving a life-affirming culture. Both NGOs and businesses would frame their work as a contribution to the Great Transition to a life-affirming culture. The media would regularly report on improvements in environmental indicators (while noting how much more we have to do).

However, for the vision of transitioning to a life-affirming global culture to have practical meaning, people need to understand what is involved and how they can contribute to the transformation within their own sphere of influence. The changes needed to pull us out of our current ecological nosedive are massive. The article Understanding Whole System Change explains what is involved, and gives examples of practical action at every level from childrearing to industrial design to global governance.

How might we act to make hope realistic for young people?

By each of us communicating through our networks to inspire mainstream commitment to transitioning to a life-sustaining society… and helping people we know think through what is involved.

Each of us can do this through our own initiative. There is no need to join – or form – a massive organisation. Seeing what is needed, we can just get on with the job. Ready-to-use communication tools are at (aka Inspiring Transition).

It’s time to think big. Although none of our networks are huge in absolute terms, when we include friends, clients, business colleagues and their extended networks the combined networkof the whole environmental/progressive/consciousness movement is huge.

The ultimate test of effectiveness

Ultimately, the test is: are we living within planetary boundaries? Have we evolved a society that does its best to take care of people, communities and the environment?

If so, the question of hope would not even arise. Let’s go for it!


Here is a very simple concept with profound implicationsfor our own wellbeing, and for large-scale social change. It is our capacity to observe ourselves without judgement. The part of our psyche that can do this might be called the Witness, or Observer Self. The label does not matter. What counts is our capacity for self-observation. So we might say that

The Witness is that part of ourselves that can see exactly what we do without judgement.

It is right next door to the Critic, which sees the same thing and at times gives us holy hell for it!

You may be very familiar with your Critic, even if you never labelled as such.  It can manifest as a voice in your head that says You should've done this; You didn't do that right, and the like. Activating our Witness function enables us to get some distance from the inner Critic. This reduces its power.

How do we activate our Witness? Just pause for a moment and notice what you are thinking right now.

That’s it. By the very act of noticing you are using your witness function.

There can be aspects of our emotional life that we take for granted. If we often find ourselves emotionally acting with anger, resentment and the like, then we are not masters of our own house. Our emotional reactions run us. This causes pain to both ourselves and others. Although we may accept the situation as ‘just the way things are’, we do not have to.

Our Witness function enables us to detect emotional reactions that do not serve us. There are many techniques for resolving these reactions. One of the simplest ones – and a very valuable one – is to be alert enough to catch these emotional reactions when they first start up, and not give them energy. In time their intensity reduces or disappears.

There are techniques for directly resolving our emotional reactions as well. For example, EFT (Emotional Freedom Techniques) is a very effective do-it-yourself technique. EFT and other techniques start with noticing ‘occasions of upset’ – inner reactions that disturb us. We become alert to these reactions. This is the first step to resolving them.

Thus our Witness is a gateway to becoming emotionally clear and happy.


It is helpful to practice using our Witness. This Object Concentration exercise is an excellent way to do this. It is a creativity exercise that sharpens our perception.

Object Concentration Exercise

Choose an attractive object to be your point of focus - e.g. a leaf, a flower, or an ornate old bell.

Observe your object for 4 minutes, following this internal instruction to yourself:

When my mind goes away I will notice that it has gone away and bring it back.

  • What details did you notice towards the end that you didn't pick up at the beginning?
  • Were you able to notice that you mind went away, and bring it back?"

Here we are paying attention to physical reality and to the operation of our own mind at the same time. This is an excellent creativity exercise. By attending acutely we notice things that we might otherwise have missed. I sometimes say that ‘to see reality is a great creative act’.

Introduce a friend to the Witness

The Witness is a very simple concept. You can easily introduce the idea of the Witness to a friend, and take them through the Object Concentration exercise. If you do so appropriately, this may be a great service to them.

How does this relate to large scale social change?

When a critical mass of people have cool heads and can assess threats (or absence of threats) realistically, we are less likely to be swept up in irrational emotional reactions that lead to war. For example, when the World Trade Centre was destroyed in New York, a measured response would have been to increase security. Of course. The irrational response was to invade Afghanistan, launch a ‘war on terror’, and in the United States pass the Homeland Security act, which curtailed citizen freedoms and some think moved US towards being a totalitarian state. Enormous resources (trillions of dollars) went into to this that could have been applied to community well-being and environmental restoration.


After decades of big business interests and beholden governments rolling back the positive environmental protection initiatives of the 1970s, it is time for those of us who care about a positive future to go on the offensive. We should aim to win – to change the direction of society so profoundly that we successfully transition from a course of sure ecological self-destruction to a life sustaining future.

To win we have to affect people’s thinking

The most influential point of change in any human system is in people’s ‘paradigms’, meaning their way of understanding the world, their appreciation of the implications of current trends, the sense of connection or disconnection to the larger web of life, and their feelings and aspirations. In other words, we should be aiming to profoundly affect how mainstream people think and feel.

Melbourne, Saturday 20 February

Turn your concern about the future into leadership. Come learn an exciting new approach to conducting powerful conversations about how to turn things around in our time of accelerating environmental destruction.

In my view most of us who are activists need to raise our game.

In 2014 Joel Makower, CEO of GreenBiz, commented: Despite its real achievements, the sustainability movement is failing.

Unless we think innovatively and mobilise passionate mainstream commitment to turning things around the continuation of business as usual will take current trends to their dismal conclusion.